"Computer programs" besides broad a category, it seems ...This decision, which dates dorsum to xvi Jan 2006, mysteriously appeared on this morning's alternative of novel cases on Lawtel. It's Intelliq v Datasphere, an appeal from the United Kingdom of Great Britain as well as Northern Ireland Trade Marks Registry that was heard past times Lord Chancellor's Appointed Person Geoffrey Hobbs QC (full text from the Patent Office website here).
Intelliq applied to revoke Datasphere's figurative grade which was essentially the discussion DATASPHERE inwards uppercase letters (portrayed, above right, amongst other material). This grade was registered for figurer software, tapes, disks as well as other related products. According to Intelliq in that place had been no genuine usage of the grade inwards the U.K. past times Datasphere or amongst its consent inwards relation to whatever goods for which the grade was registered. The hearing officeholder ruled that the specification of the registration of DATASPHERE should live on restricted to figurer software as well as figurer programs. Intelliq appealed, tilt that the testify filed past times Datasphere was insufficient to found genuine usage of the grade for whatever of the goods for which it was registered, since all it showed was usage inwards relation to services. Intelliq also argued that the testify of usage did non justify the retentiveness of the registration for all forms of figurer software as well as figurer programs.
Geoffrey Hobbs QC ruled every bit follows: * While the testify was thin, the hearing officeholder had been required to assess it every bit a whole as well as was entitled to regard it every bit indicative of a course of written report or designing of dealing inwards which the merchandise grade was used inwards the United Kingdom of Great Britain as well as Northern Ireland during the 5 years preceding the engagement of the application for revocation.
* An social club reducing the range of a specification of goods should seat as well as define not particular examples of goods for which in that place had been genuine usage but the item categories of goods they should realistically live on taken to exemplify.
* In relation to the extremely broad arrive at of products covered past times figurer software as well as figurer programs, the testify indid non exhibit usage of the merchandise grade inwards relation to figurer software as well as figurer programs inwards general: it indicated alone that usage of the grade was express to items embodying figurer software as well as figurer programs for specific purposes, Datasphere clearly existence a specialist provider of niche figurer software as well as programs. The testify of usage was withal insufficient to justify retentiveness of the registration for all types of figurer software as well as figurer programs.
* The specification of goods for which the grade was to rest registered nether was thus reduced as well as so every bit to encompass figurer software as well as figurer programs all for usage inwards or amongst banking or fiscal telecommunication systems.
agrees that testify of usage must back upwards the registration, but he recalls the Court of First Instance conclusion inwards ALADIN/ALADDIN (Case T-126/03), inwards which that courtroom allowed an appeal against an over-narrowing of the range of registration of a merchandise grade for metallic cleaners. At present, practise appears inconsistent every bit betwixt dissimilar descriptions of goods (computer programs are besides wide, but pharma products aren't; metallic cleaners are somewhere betwixt the two): what nosotros postulate is a reference to the ECJ or an appeal from the CFI to clarify the extent to which usage inside share of a description of goods justifies the continued registration of a grade for the entire description of goods. Merpel says, how effective is partial revocation here? The products for which DATASPHERE is no longer registered are soundless probable to live on "similar goods" when considering the likelihood of confusion inwards infringement as well as opposition proceedings.Other interesting words ending inwards "Q" here, here and here
Avenue Q here
What to produce amongst your Q here
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar